***I'm feeling snarky today. You've been warned.***
The New York Times ran a story yesterday titled "Placing the Blame as Students Are Buried in Debt." It features the travails of 26 year old Cortney Munna who graduated from New York University in 2005 with more than $100,000 in student loan debt. Nearly 5 years after graduation, Ms Munna still has almost the whole amount to pay off.
The article neatly lays out the list of corporate baddies who preyed ruthlessly on Ms Munna, laying the lion's share of the blame at the feet of her alma mater, arguing that the university "had an obligation to counsel students like Ms. Munna, who got in too far over their heads." Poor Ms Munna was taken advantage of by everyone with whom she came into contact, it seems. The only person who remains blameless in all of this is poor Ms Munna herself.
I looked up the fees for NYU on their website. A basic education at this fine institution costs a commuter student, which Ms Munna was, $40,082 a year. Assuming that she was a perfect student who never had to add/drop a class, changed majors, or had to retake a class for any reason, the total cost of a four year degree is $160,328. She's lucky she only owes the $100,000. I don't understand her surprise at the total amount of her bill. Do they not teach mathematics in New York?
The bottom line is that Ms Munna went to a very expensive school. She knew the cost; her mother knew the cost, but they both decided to ignore the tally. As her mother said, "All I could see was college, and a good college and how proud I was of her." I understand motherly pride, but was there no pause when Sallie Mae refused to loan them any more money because of the extreme debt they had amassed? They charged headlong over to Citibank and borrowed another $40,000.
Now Ms Munna would like some government agency to swoop in and make her debt go away since she's unable to earn enough to pay it back. Didn't I tell you? She majored in religious and women's studies. What kind of job can you get with a degree in feminism? Something in San Francisco that pays $20 an hour (that's equivalent to earning $12 in the rest of the country). It just seems to be common sense to me that if you're going to get a 6-figure education, you should make sure that a 7-figure job is waiting for you at the end of it.
I find it funny and a little ironic that Ms Munna spent 150-grand and 4 years learning how to hate men, and now is whining to the newspaper about how "the Man" should bail her out.
11 comments:
The last line was perfect.
She could have saved $100K and just volunteered at her local Call-to-Action chapter, and learned to hate men on the cheap.
You may snark all you want.
Ha! Ha! Ha!
Ain't it just Too Bad(TM)?
I borrowed my money AND paid it back by working -- I don't feel bad for anybody.
@LarryD - good one!
Great post. And I love the first comment.
BRILLIANT post! Thank you for saying what needs to be said!
you would Like to think a college of that caliber, or any college for that matter would instill some fiscal responsibility to their students. Sadly, They don't appear to.
Great Post! My husband is finishing up his PhD and it is for his work--he teaches college English/comp/rhetoric/technical writing. He was told he kind of had to go on with his studies. Of course, we don't have the money for that. BUT, we got the loans (totaling a little more than 20,000) and we know that we will pay them back. My husband will have job security and options to work elsewhere. We wouldn't accept a bailout if someone tried to--you know, confession and all.
This chick knew what she was doing. She needs to pay.
Love, Suzanne
Amen!
Thank you! I loved the last line. I think the masses have all gone bananas. Just get a job and start paying it off - she can hate men at any old job out there.
Great post! We are paying off college debt as well, but I help by using coupons, buying only the essentials, and my husband does a little thing called "working".... :)
Student loans are one thing, not paying them is something totally different.
I worked, had a scholarship and what later became known as Pell grants but I still had to borrow some money to make ends meet.
At graduation, I owed one third of my starting annual salary as a teacher. When I went on maternity leave at the end of my second year of teaching, that loan was paid off.
Somehow, I wonder how much responsibility was ever inculcated into her growing up.
Post a Comment